Consignment and Thrift Shops in the Annapolis Area

Variety, Affordable, Community Focused, Quality

By Darla Winstead - Publisher of Macaroni Kid Annapolis November 11, 2023

My daughter, Kat and I visited area Consignment and Thrift Shops to check them out and see what treasures we could find. We decided to share our impressions of each shop with you in the hope you might find a new place for bargains. They are listed in alphabetical order. Happy Shopping!  

The opinions expressed in this article are ours and we were not compensated in any way.


One thing we learned is that not all consignment and thrift shops are created equally.  

  • Some were a delightful and fun shopping experience. 
  • One resembled a high-end boutique with quality items for the women in the family.
  • Several had the mission to help the community. 
  • A few were a little run down and lacked pizazz.   

Goodwill Retail Store - Annapolis

1605 West St, Annapolis  

Hours: M-Sa 10-7, Su 11-6

Goodwill Retail Store - Edgewater   

3153 Solomons Island Road, Edgewater

Hours: M-Sa 10-7, Su 11-6


Goodwill has convenient locations and hours. They carry a wide variety of items at very low prices. Both locations have plenty of free parking. A good place to buy casual and formal clothing. Our go-to place for costumes. Goodwill helps the community by providing job training and opportunities for people with disabilities.  


LMS Compassion Place in Annapolis

230 West St, Annapolis  410-269-5016

M-F 9-4, Sa 10-2, Su closed


LMS has a good variety of clothing, housewares, nic nacs, and furniture at very affordable prices. A good place to get items for a first apartment. The day we were there you could fill a bag of clothing for $10, now that's a bargain. The Annapolis location is one Compassion Place out of many, located around Maryland and run by the Lutheran Mission Society. Besides selling items, LMS gives away free food and has a chapel to care for your spiritual needs. The staff were very friendly. Parking at LMS is limited but there is metered street parking and two parking garages within a few blocks.  

New to You Consignment Shop

1916 Forest Dr,  Annapolis  410-263-2211

Hours: M-Sa 10-5:45, Su 12-5


New to You is laid out well and even though the store is very full, it was organized and provided a comfortable shopping experience. A really nice selection of clothing for all ages and needs. We enjoyed browsing and found a few unexpected items: motorcycle helmet, new Kitchen Aid mixer still in the box, Hummel figurines, and a designer blouse with the tag attached. The location is easy to access and has plenty of parking.  At New to You, we always find something we "need" at a very good price.  

One Petticoat Lane

2 Annapolis St, Annapolis  410-541-6443

Hours: W & Th 11-5, F & Sa 11-4, Su 11-3, M & Tu closed


One Petticoat Lane is a beautiful boutique located in West Annapolis. When shopping, you forget you are in a consignment shop. The purses and other items are displayed so nicely. The women's clothing and accessories are stylish and of very good quality. Although the items are high-end you will find something that fits your budget. There is a parking lot behind the shop. We enjoyed our visit to One Petticoat Lane and meeting Stella, the lovely owner.      

Return to Oz Consignments

2011 West St, Annapolis  410-266-9390

Hours: M-Sa 10-5, Su 12-4


Return to Oz is located in a two-story building and is very well organized. Although the rooms are small, it's fairly easy to get around. When my daughter was younger she loved their shoes and clothing and found many items to add to her wardrobe. The store has a lot of clothing and accessories for all ages and genders. They also have toys, books, and items for your home. Everything is of good quality and affordable. The small parking lot is on the corner of two very busy streets and a little difficult to access but worth the effort.     

Other Stores - Not Reviewed

Navy Marine Corps Relief Society Thrift Shop

31 Alder Rd., Annapolis 410-293-4402  

Hours: Tu/Th 10am - 1pm

St. Andrews Thrift Store

Saint Andrews United Methodist Church and School

4 Wallace Manor Rd., Edgewater  443-569-2290

Hours: M-Th 1-4pm, Sa 7am-11am, F/Su Closed 

Joy Thrift Shop 

Joy Reigns Lutheran Church

35 Mayo Rd., Edgewater   410-266-5691

Hours: Sat and Mon 9am-12pm